March 2025

Career counselling without people? Why smart algorithms are shaping careers

How AI and smart algorithms are reshaping career counseling: Opportunities, risks, and the impact of data-driven tools on professional paths.

← BACK TO THE OVERVIEW
← BACK TO THE OVERVIEW
Looking for new employees?
Do not hesitate to contact us for a free consultation.

Already in 2023, IBM made a bold statement: AI won’t replace managers, but managers who use AI will replace those who don’t. It’s not just a catchy phrase—it’s happening. More and more companies are integrating AI into employee development, leadership coaching, and career planning. The reason? It’s cheaper, faster, and sometimes even more effective than traditional career consulting.

Take CoachHub and Microsoft, for example. They recently launched the world's first conversational AI career coach, AIMY – it’s designed to bring personalized coaching to every employee, 24/7. No more waiting weeks for an expensive career advisor. No more limited access to professional development. AI is pushing career coaching from an exclusive leadership perk to an everyday workplace tool. And businesses are betting big on it.

But the real question is: Can an AI truly understand what motivates a person? Can it really guide a professional through a complex career shift the way a human mentor would? Or are we heading into a future where job coaching is reduced to cold, algorithm-driven assessments?

This article looks at how AI is reshaping career coaching, where it works effortlessly, where it still struggles, and what it means for companies investing in employee development. Because one thing is obvious—ignoring this shift is no longer an option.

How Is AI Transforming the Accessibility and Scalability of Career Coaching?

Breaking the Executive Barrier

Career coaching has traditionally been reserved for top executives, with sessions costing hundreds of euros per hour. AI-driven career coaching platforms, however, are making career development accessible to a much broader audience. Employees at all levels can now receive personalized career guidance without the high costs and scheduling constraints of human coaching.

Companies like Oracle, CoachHub and the German AI start-up Retorio are leading the way in this transformation. Oracle’s AI-powered coaching system tailors career development plans, offers upskilling recommendations, and assists employees in preparing for leadership roles. 

CoachHub’s AI mentor, AIMY, developed in collaboration with Microsoft, adapts to an employee’s career stage and professional aspirations, providing 24/7 coaching in multiple languages. Meanwhile, Retorio’s behavioral AI analyzes employees’ video responses to help them improve communication, leadership presence, and customer interactions.

Personalized, Data-Driven Career Planning

One of the key advantages of AI-powered career coaching is its ability to process large volumes of data to offer hyper-personalized advice. By analyzing an employee’s skills, work history, industry trends, and job market fluctuations, AI-driven coaching platforms can generate tailored career development roadmaps.

For example, Oracle’s AI coach not only recommends potential career paths but also suggests specific courses, certifications, and networking opportunities to help employees advance. AI-driven career tools are also being embedded within HR systems, allowing organizations to proactively guide employees toward high-demand internal roles, improving retention and workforce agility.

Scalability: Career Coaching for the Many, Not Just the Few

AI-powered career coaching doesn’t just personalize career guidance—it scales it across entire organizations. Traditional human coaching is limited by availability and cost, whereas AI solutions can simultaneously support thousands of employees. This is particularly valuable for large enterprises, consulting firms, and global organizations, where providing one-on-one coaching for every employee is impractical.

Cost-effectiveness is another key driver of AI’s rise in career coaching. Human coaches often charge €100–€300 per session, making widespread career coaching programs financially unfeasible for most companies. AI-driven career development tools, however, offer continuous, on-demand support at a fraction of the cost. Companies investing in AI-powered coaching not only save money but also equip their employees with career guidance at scale, boosting engagement and internal mobility.

Is AI the Future of Career Coaching?

Are humans now completely out of the equation? Although AI-powered career coaching offers significant advantages in terms of accessibility and scalability, human mentors will not be completely replaced. AI-driven tools work best in combination with people who bring the emotional intelligence, industry experience and nuanced judgement that AI still lacks.

However, AI-powered career coaching is no longer a futuristic concept—it’s already reshaping how professionals approach career growth. Organisations that integrate AI-supported tools for career development today give their employees and themselves a competitive advantage that should not be underestimated.

Practical Applications of AI in Employee Development

AI is not just reshaping career coaching—it is becoming an active career companion for employees. From identifying skill gaps to suggesting upskilling opportunities, AI-powered tools are helping employees take charge of their professional growth.

Platforms like Oracle AI Coach analyze an employee’s experience and generate personalized career progression plans. These tools recommend learning paths, internal mobility options, and networking opportunities that align with an employee’s ambitions.

For those looking to transition into new roles, AI-powered career coaching platforms can highlight transferable skills, suggest relevant certifications, and even provide step-by-step roadmaps for position shifts.

Identifying and Closing Skill Gaps with AI

One of AI’s most valuable applications in career development is its ability to detect and bridge skill gaps in employees. Traditional learning and development programs often rely on standardized training modules that may not align with an individual's specific weaknesses or career aspirations. AI, however, can analyze an employee’s performance data, completed projects, and learning history to create a personalized upskilling roadmap.

AI-powered platforms assess which skills an employee already possesses, which ones are lacking, and how those gaps compare to the requirements of their desired role. For example, if an employee aims to transition into a leadership position, AI can determine whether they lack strategic decision-making, conflict resolution, or advanced project management skills. Based on this analysis, the system recommends specific courses, mentorship opportunities, or real-world projects that will help close these gaps.

By using AI to pinpoint learning needs at an individual level, companies can ensure that employees develop the right skills at the right time, making career growth more efficient and data-driven. Instead of generic training paths, AI enables dynamic, real-time learning journeys, tailored to an employee’s strengths, weaknesses, and career goals.

What Are the Limitations and Ethical Considerations of AI Career Coaching?

While AI-powered career coaching provides impressive scalability and personalization, it has inherent limitations. One of the biggest challenges is the lack of emotional intelligence—AI cannot replicate the human touch required for motivation, deep career reflection, and handling sensitive issues. Another concern is bias in AI algorithms. AI models rely on training data, and if this data contains biases, career recommendations may unintentionally reinforce inequalities in hiring and promotion. 

Data privacy is another major issue, as AI-driven career coaches require large amounts of personal information to function effectively. Employees may be hesitant to share career aspirations or weaknesses if they fear misuse of their data. Companies must implement clear ethical guidelines and bias detection mechanisms to ensure fair and transparent AI career coaching. These concerns highlight the need for human oversight to ensure AI remains a tool for empowerment rather than a barrier to career advancement.

How Are Companies Implementing AI-Powered Coaching for Leadership Development?

Next, let's look at a few real-world examples.

Cisco: AI-Powered Leadership Training at Scale

Cisco has integrated AI-driven coaching to support leadership development across its global teams. The system uses AI-driven conversation simulations to help managers refine their communication, conflict resolution, and decision-making skills. The AI platform provides real-time feedback and suggests improvement areas, helping managers adapt to different leadership scenarios.

Skillsoft’s AI Mentor (CAISY): First-Time Managers in Focus

Skillsoft’s AI mentor, CAISY, is specifically designed to help first-time managers navigate the complexities of leadership. It provides personalized coaching sessions that cover team management, employee motivation, and strategic decision-making. CAISY also integrates into daily workflows, offering bite-sized coaching modules to reinforce learning over time.

Multiverse’s AI Assistant “Atlas”: Career Development on Demand

Multiverse’s AI assistant, Atlas, focuses on long-term career planning by using AI-driven data analysis to suggest individualized career pathways, training programs, and mentorship opportunities. Employees receive personalized recommendations based on their performance data and career goals, ensuring ongoing professional growth.

Conclusion

AI-powered career coaching brings scalability, accessibility and data-driven insights to career development. However, it does not replace human coaching – it enhances it. A hybrid model is most effective, with AI providing scalable, data-driven insights and human mentors offering emotional intelligence and in-depth expertise.

One of the most important insights from companies like Cisco and Skillsoft is that AI is not only an efficiency tool – it is a catalyst for more structured and targeted career development. By automating repetitive tasks, AI enables career coaches and HR teams to focus on higher-value interactions, such as mentoring for executives and strategic career planning.

Want to speak to an expert?

Subscribe to our newsletter